Calling 1953 "not ... the best year in mystery writing," author-critic
Dorothy B. Hughes selected her favorite mysteries of the year in a December 6, 1953, column for the
Washington Post. They were:
•
Christianna Brand,
Fog of Doubt.
"Artful puzzle."
•
Leslie Ford,
Washington Whispers Murder."Tells, with the bite of intelligent scorn, a terrifying story."
•
Max Franklin [
Richard Deming],
Justice Has No Sword. "This one has the professional touch of a star reporter."
•
Michael Gilbert,
Fear to Tread. "Another great Michael Gilbert novel."
• Charlotte Jay,
Beat Not the Bones. "The first important mystery of the year."
•
Ira Levin,
A Kiss before Dying. "Another big first, written by a 23-year-old."
•
René Masson,
Green Oranges. "Masson is one of the great discoveries of this decade."
•
William McGivern,
The Big Heat. "Today's first-ranking novelist of the hard-hitting mystery."
•
Josephine Tey,
The Singing Sands. "Her noted blend of detecting excitement and beautiful writing."